Jewish American Heritage Month

Posted By admin on January 14, 2020

This article was featured in One Great Story, New Yorks reading recommendation newsletter. Sign up here to get it nightly.

Irony, declared dead after 9/11, is alive and kicking in Trumps America. Its the concepts of truth and shame that are on life support. The definition of facts has been so thoroughly vandalized that Americans can no longer agree on what one is, and our president has barreled through so many crimes and misdemeanors with so few consequences that its impossible to gainsay his claim that he could shoot someone on Fifth Avenue and get away with it. Donald Trump proves daily that there is no longer any penalty for doing wrong as long as you deny everything, never say youre sorry, and have co-conspirators stashed in powerful places to put the fix in.

No wonder so many fear that Trump will escape his current predicament scot-free, with a foregone acquittal at his impeachment trial in the GOP-controlled Senate and a pull-from-behind victory in November, buoyed by a booming economy, fractious Democrats, and a stacked Electoral College. The enablers and apologists who have facilitated his triumph over the rule of law happily agree. John Kennedy, the Louisiana senator who parrots Vladimir Putins talking points in his supine defense of Trump, acts as if there will never be a reckoning. While he has no relation to the president whose name he incongruously bears, his every craven statement bespeaks a confidence that history will count him among the knights of the buffet table in the gilded Mar-a-Lago renovation of Camelot. He is far from alone.

If we can extricate ourselves even briefly from our fatalistic fog, however, we might give some credence to a wider view. For all the damage inflicted since Inauguration Day 2017, America is still standing, a majority of Americans disapprove of Trump, and the laws of gravity, if not those of the nation, remain in full force. Moral gravity may well reassert its pull, too, with time. Rather than being the end of American history as we know it, the Trump presidency may prove merely a notorious chapter in that history. Heedless lapdogs like Kennedy, Devin Nunes, and Lindsey Graham are acting now as if there is no tomorrow, but tomorrow will come eventually, whatever happens in the near future, and Judgment Day could arrive sooner than they think. That judgment will be rendered by an ever-more demographically diverse America unlikely to be magnanimous toward cynical politicians who prioritized pandering to Trumps dwindling all-white base over the common good.

All cults come to an end, often abruptly, and Trumps Republican Party is nothing if not a cult. While cult leaders are generally incapable of remorse whether they be totalitarian rulers, sexual Svengalis, or the self-declared messiahs of crackpot religions their followers almost always pay a human and reputational price once the leader is toppled. We dont know how and when Donald Trump will exit, but under any scenario it wont be later than January 20, 2025. Even were he to be gone tomorrow, the legacy of his most powerful and servile collaborators is already indelibly bound to his.

Whether these enablers joined his administration in earnest, or aided and abetted it from elite perches in politics, Congress, the media, or the private sector, they will be remembered for cheering on a leader whose record in government (thus far) includes splitting up immigrant families and incarcerating their children in cages; encouraging a spike in racist, xenophobic, and anti-Semitic vigilantes; leveraging American power to promote ethnic cleansing abroad and punish political opponents at home; actively inciting climate change and environmental wreckage; and surrendering Americas national security to an international rogues gallery of despots.

That selective short list doesnt take into account any new White House felonies still to come, any future repercussions here and abroad of Trumps actions to date, or any previous foul deeds that have so far eluded public exposure. For all the technological quickening of the media pulse in this century, Trumps collaborators will one day be viewed through the long lens of history like Nixons collaborators before them and the various fools, opportunists, and cowards who tried to appease Hitler in America, England, and France before that. Once Trump has vacated the Oval Office, and possibly for decades thereafter, his government, like any other deposed strongmans, will be subjected to a forensic colonoscopy to root out buried crimes, whether against humanity or the rule of law or both. With time, everything will come out it always does. With time, the ultimate fates of those brutalized immigrant and refugee families will emerge in full. And Trumps collaborators, our Vichy Republicans, will own all of it whether they were active participants in the wrongdoing like Jared Kushner, Stephen Miller, Kirstjen Nielsen, Mike Pompeo, and William Barr, or the so-called adults in the room who stood idly by rather than sound public alarms for the good of the Republic (e.g., Gary Cohn, John Kelly, Rex Tillerson), or those elite allies beyond the White House gates who pretended not to notice administration criminality and moral atrocities in exchange for favors like tax cuts and judicial appointments (from Mitch McConnell and Paul Ryan to Franklin Graham and Jerry Falwell Jr.).

Such Trump collaborators are kidding themselves if they think that post-Trump image-laundering through good works or sheer historical amnesia will cleanse their names of the Trump taint as easily as his residential complexes in Manhattan have shed their Trump signage. A century of history and not just American history says otherwise.

To take two examples from the Nixon era, the White House criminals Charles Colson and Jeb Stuart Magruder both found God and dedicated themselves to ministries after doing time for Watergate-related crimes. (They were among 69 charged and 25 imprisoned.) But you wont find their ostentatious efforts at spiritual redemption at the top of their Wikipedia entries or referenced more than fleetingly in the vast Nixon-Watergate literature. Nixon lackeys who did nothing illegal generally fared no better: The New Jersey congressman Charles Sandman, a House Judiciary Committee impeachment holdout until a few days before Nixons resignation, lost a seat he had held since 1966 in the subsequent 1974 midterms (48 other GOP members of Congress were wiped out as well) and would wind up the decade dishing out steamed crabs at a joint on the Jersey shore and losing a jury trial on the charge of slandering a police officer. When a Senate counterpart, Ed Gurney of Florida, a vocal Nixon defender on Sam Ervins Watergate Committee, died in 1996, his family tried to keep his death a secret, presumably to avoid renewed attention to his past.

Some Nixon loyalists on Capitol Hill escaped oblivion most notably the Mississippi congressman Trent Lott, from a district that had voted 87 percent for Nixon in 1972 (Nixons strongest in the nation). So did some White House flacks well removed from Watergate like Pat Buchanan and Diane Sawyer. Others, prefiguring Sean Spicers debasement onDancing With the Stars,landed B-list (and lower) media gigs: The Watergate burglar G. Gordon Liddy appeared on televisionsMiami ViceandMacGyver,and a ditzy Jesuit speechwriter prominent in the White House spin offensive, John McLaughlin, found a secular throne for himself at an odious Beltway chatfest,The McLaughlin Group,after abandoning the priesthood. Like their Trump counterparts, countless Watergate principals wrote tell-all books, many of them best sellers, running the gamut from H.R. HaldemansThe Ends of Powerto John EhrlichmansWitness to Power.

But there arent any die-hard Nixon supporters in either chamber of Congress who are now remembered as patriots, no matter what else they did with their careers before, during, or after his presidency. The figures who live on are those like Ervin and Judge Sirica, who brought Nixon to justice, and, as the historian David Greenberg has noted, those loyalists who abandoned Nixon early, when it mattered.

HuffPost reported in 2017 that the Trump Justice Department took down the portrait of one of the few heroes who stood up to Nixons abuses of power from within his administration, Attorney General Elliot Richardson. Whether Richardsons deaccession was an act of denial, gallows humor, or a conscious or subconscious admission of guilt, it was an impotent gesture not least because Watergate has with time proved an inadequate analogy for Trumps metastasizing scandals. The stench of disrepute that will cling to Trumps collaborators is likely to exceed the posthumous punishment of Nixons dead-enders for the simple reason that Nixons White House horrors werent in the same league.

In both cases, impeachment was driven by the revelations of illegal efforts to sabotage a rival presidential candidate and the ensuing cover-ups. But the gravity of the specifics differ by several orders of magnitude. The cash that Nixon & Co.tapped to fund the break-in to the Democratic National Committee headquarters (and the subsequent hush money to the burglars) came from his own donors; Trump, by contrast, sought to bankroll his effort to dig up dirt on the Bidens by appropriating nearly $400 million in Congress-mandated foreign aid paid for by taxpayers. And while the Nixon White House hired freelance bumblers to spy on the Democrats, Trump commandeered a cabal of Cabinet officers, diplomats, and Rudy Giulianirecruited thugs to try to muscle the head of state of a foreign ally into doing his bidding.

The disproportionality between Trumps history and Nixons hardly ends there. Trump is not Hitler, but some of his actions, starting with his repeated, barely coded endorsements of white supremacists, suggest its not for want of trying. Nixon and his vice-president, Spiro Agnew, exploited racial resentments and backlash to the civil-rights movement to attract bigots to the GOP through a new southern strategy. Ugly as that was (and is), it pales next to Trump and his campaigns explicit alignment with those fine people who stir hate, bullying, and incendiary alt-right conspiracy theories into an inflammatory dark-web brew. However much Trumps courtiers try to compartmentalize, they cant separate themselves from his flirtations with neo-Nazis.

Nor can Trumps enablers escape the stain of his alliances with murderous neo-Hitlers and neo-Stalins in Russia, Syria, Turkey, Hungary, Brazil, and North Korea. Whatever else is to be said about Nixon, not for a second would he have favored the worldview and national interests of a strongman like Putin over that of America and its allies, or taken Putins word as a former KGB agent over that of Americas own intelligence agencies. Its this aspect of Trumpian rule that sinks to depths previously unfathomable for an American president and makes Trumps collaborators look less like the corrupt government bureaucrats and hacks ofAll the Presidents Menand more like the traitorous elites who wittingly or idiotically enabled Hitler in the 1930s.

The notion of Vichy Republicans is hardly hyperbole. Christopher R. Browning, an American historian of the Holocaust and World War IIera Europe,wrote in theNew York Review of Booksin 2018 that those who rationalized their original support for Trump on the grounds of Better Trump than Hillary and are now reupping for 2020 are channeling those on the right who proclaimed Better Hitler than Blum in France in the 1930s. Such Frenchmen, Browning writes, went so far as to empower their countrys traditional national enemy across the Rhine and its Nazi dictator rather than reelect the sitting prime minister, Lon Blum, a Jewish socialist who would have preserved French democracy. (In defeat, Blum would become an opponent of Vichy and end up in Buchenwald.)

Make no mistake: The current Better Trump than Warren (or Sanders) crowd is repeating this history. Their credo might as well be Better Putin, Erdogan, and Assad than Warren, for Trump is serving as an unabashed proxy for our present-day mini-Hitlers while simultaneously trying to transform American democracy into an Ultimate Fighting Championship ring of chaos, corruption, and dysfunction. Prominent Trump supporters like Kennedy, of course, fiercely deny that they are pro-Putin (even though the president himself never has), but that doesnt vitiate the real-world consequence that by standing with Trump, they are advancing the interests of Russia even as it conducts cyberwar against their own country and threatens some of the same American allies Hitler did.

You dont have to be a card-carrying fascist to collaborate with fascists and help them seize power; you just have to be morally bankrupt and self-serving. As the authoritative American historian of Vichy France, Robert O. Paxton, has pointed out, it was only a rather small minority of Frances wartime collaborators who were motivated by an actual ideological sympathy with Nazism and Fascism to go along with the Nazi puppet regime fronted by Marshal Philippe Ptain in Vichy. A more widespread incentive was personal gain. Others rationalized their complicity by persuading themselves they were acting in the national interest. It would be no surprise if that distribution of motivations persists among Trump collaborators today. Such backers as the financier Stephen Schwarzman and New York real-estate titans like Stephen Ross of Hudson Yards no doubt congratulate themselves on acting in the national interest while pocketing personal gains measured in either political influence or on a profit-and-loss statement.

In France, such ostensible moral distinctions among collaborators were rendered moot in the long-delayed and gruesome postwar reckoning. All roads led to the same destination: Starting in 1942, Vichy shipped some 76,000 Jews in mass deportations to their doom. The exiled were mostly foreign refugees, Paxton writes, who had previously relied upon traditional French hospitality. Their blood was on every collaborators hands. The collaborators common postwar defense that things would have been far worse if they had not been working on the inside was repurposed by the Trump official responsible for the brutal treatment of immigrants who had relied upon traditional American humanity. John F. Kelly Says His Tenure As Trumps Chief of Staff Is Best Measured by What the President Did Not Do read the headline of the exit interview he gave the Los Angeles Times. Good luck with that in the long-term court of public opinion. France wrestled with Vichys legacy for decades before 1995, when the French president Jacques Chirac abjured denial and officially confirmed his nations complicity in the wholesale deportation of Jews.

If you look backat the elite figures who lent their clout and prestige to clearing Hitlers path before or during World War II, its striking how such folly and inhumanity remains immutable across national boundaries and centuries. The amalgam of nationalism, isolationism, and nativism embraced by Trump shares its DNA not just with the Ptainists of France but Neville Chamberlains appeasement cohort in England and America First, the movement whose name Trump appropriated without (of course) knowing what it was. America First, though originating as a campus-centric peace campaign, was hijacked by a rancid mob of Hitler acolytes and peace-at-any-price dupes that included, most famously, Charles Lindbergh. Many of these Hitler enablers had elaborate rationalizations for their actions that mirror those of Trumps highest-profile shills today. Robert Taft, the hard-right isolationist senator from Ohio, wrote the script for Better Trump than Hillaryism nearly a century ago: America should not go to war with Germany, he argued, because there is a good deal more danger of the infiltration of totalitarian ideas from the New Deal circles in Washington than there will ever be from the activities of the Nazis.

Another parallel is exemplified by the Trump collaborator and donor Gordon Sondland, even now, somehow, still the ambassador to the European Union. Hes a zhlubby discount-rack answer to Joseph Kennedy, a far more successful and clever mogul who served as Franklin Roosevelts ambassador to the U.K. from 1937 to 1940. Until FDR shut him down, Kennedy tried to conduct a rogue foreign policy to advance Chamberlains appeasement efforts to the point of counseling the Nazis that they could get away with brutalizing Jews if they would just do so with less loud clamor. Much as Sondland, Trump, and Giuliani thought nothing of leaving Ukraine vulnerable to Putins aggression by holding back military aid, so Kennedy thought that Hitler should be free to conquer expendable smaller countries in Eastern Europe. I cant for the life of me understand why anybody would want to go to war to save the Czechs, he wrote in a draft of a speech before the White House nixed it. As went the Czechs then, so have gone the Ukrainians and Kurds today.

The antecedents for Trumpist enablers from the tycoon sector both within and outside the White House Cohn, Schwarzman, Steven Mnuchin, Wilbur Ross, et al. can be found in those now-vilified captains of 1930s American industry who were prime movers in various back-channel schemes to appease Hitler. The America First Committees members included Henry Ford, an unabashed anti-Semite who was name-checked admiringly inMein Kampf,and Avery Brundage, an Illinois construction magnate and president of the U.S. Olympic Committee who bent to Hitlers will by yanking the only two Jewish competitors on an American team in the 1936 Summer Games in Berlin. James Mooney, the General Motors overseas president in charge of its European operations and another America First committeeman, took it upon himself to do his own Giuliani-Sondland-like shadow diplomacy by securing face-to-face meetings with Hermann Gring as well as Hitler. He claimed to be seeking peace, but had he succeeded, he would have facilitated Germanys conquest of Europe much as Trump and his supplicants have been green-lighting the imperial designs of Russia and Turkey.

These businessmens machinations did not bring about peace in their time but did bring financial quid pro quos that fattened their bottom lines. Hitlers regime gave Brundages company the commission to build its new embassy in Washington. More than a half-century after V-E Day, researchers confirmed that Ford and GMs German operations had manufactured armaments for the Nazi war machine, sometimes with slave labor. Alfred P. Sloan, the longtime GM chairman, explained his philosophy: An international business operating throughout the world should conduct its operations in strictly business terms, without regard to the political beliefs of its management, or the political beliefs of the countries in which it is operating. Surely Jared Kushner, Mnuchin, and Schwarzman couldnt have put it any better as they cavorted with Mohammed bin Salman at his investment conference in Riyadh in October, a year after the murder and dismemberment of Jamal Khashoggi. As with Ford, Brundage, Mooney, and the rest, any loot they accrued in exchange for their pact with the Devil will be unearthed in good time.

While some Hitler appeasers faced swift retribution FDR shut down Joseph Kennedys personal political ambitions for good others would get their due later. In 1998, nearly four decades after his death, Mooney would at last face an accounting: Newly discovered documents, triggered in part by litigation on behalf of Holocaust survivors, would show, as the WashingtonPostput it, that in consultation with Gring, he was involved in the partial conversion of the principal GM automobile plant at Rsselsheim to production of engines and other parts for the Junker Wunderbomber, a key weapon in the German air force.

One imagines that high-toned Trump collaborators deplore Khashoggis murder (though not when in Saudi Arabia). And they may (privately) roll their eyes at Trumps palling around with bigots. For heavens sake, some of them are Jewish themselves, and so is the First Daughter! But America First also claimed to be foursquare against anti-Semitism, despite the fact that Lindbergh, Ford, and Mooney all received medals of appreciation from the Third Reich before the war. Like the Trump White House, the America First Committee deployed token Jews to try to deflect critics, including Florence Kahn, a former Republican congresswoman from California; it even hired a Jew as the first publicity director of its New York chapter. But such disingenuous stunts, like Trumps soporific teleprompter-scripted condemnation of racism, bigotry and white supremacy after mass shootings, didnt deter American Nazi wannabes from flocking to the organizations ranks, among them the followers of the unabashedly anti-Semitic radio priest Father Coughlin. Ivanka Trumps observance of the Sabbath has not stopped her father from retweeting anti-Semitic memes or prevented Jews Will Not Replace Us thugs from rallying around #MAGA.

InHitler in Los Angeles,his groundbreaking recent history of wartime Nazism in California, Steven J. Ross might as well have been writing about Charlottesville when he observes that America First enabled previously disreputable hate groups to move from the margins to the mainstream of American life and politics. The anti-Semitic dog whistles of Lindbergh and his prominent peers gave a pass to violent extremist groups of that time like the American Rangers and the Royal Order of American Defenders. The Trump GOP has revived the tradition: Not only did House members meet with Chuck Johnson, a Holocaust denier who raises money for the neo-Nazi Daily Stormer website, but Floridas irrepressible freshman congressman Matt Gaetz invited him to cheer Trump at the 2018 State of the Union.

No one can predictposteritys judgments, but if the past is any guide at all, this is not going to end well for Trumps collaborators. The Reverend Sun Myung Moon, the Unification Church cult leader who was welcomed into the Oval Office by Nixon and whose brainwashed Moonies gathered en masse on the Capitol steps to pray and fast for three days during impeachment, may have found his farcical descendants in Trumps Christian stooges. Witness the offspring of Billy Graham and Jerry Falwell the Donald Trump Jr.s, if you will, of Americas pagan Evangelical racket. Franklin Graham has preached an Old Testament parallel between Trump and David, while Jerry Jr. is now fending off inquiries into his and his wifes antics, business or otherwise, with a pool boy they befriended at the Fontainebleau Hotel in Miami Beach. (For his part, Moon was eventually engulfed by repeated post-Watergate scandals, including a conviction for tax fraud and obstruction of justice that sent him to prison in 1982.) The rhetoric of Nixons and Trumps mad-dog defenders can be interchangeable, too. Theres more than a little of the degraded Lindsey Graham in the legendaryTodayshow appearance by Earl Landgrebe, a die-hard anti-impeachment vote on the House Judiciary Committee, the day before Nixon resigned in August 1974. Dont confuse me with the facts. Ive got a closed mind, he said. I will not vote for impeachment. Im going to stick with my president even if he and I have to be taken out of this building and shot. (The voters shot him soon enough; he received only 39 percent of the vote in his safe Indiana district three months later.)

But such similarities understate the case. The stakes are much higher when an American president is putting the nation, and its Constitution, in jeopardy by abusing his power to aid Americas foreign foes. Someone like Graham is less likely to be remembered as another Landgrebe than as another Burton Wheeler, a senator from Montana who began his career as a conventional New Deal Democrat and morphed into an America First Nazi appeaser. As Graham countenanced Trumps empowering of Putin and his assault on Ukraine, so Wheeler opposed aid to England and other American allies when war broke out in Europe. He is best known now and may be in perpetuity as the fascist vice-president to Lindberghs president in Philip Roths World War II counter-history,The Plot Against America.(David Simon is soon to bring out a television version.)

Mitch McConnell has led another, even graver reenactment of the Hitler-appeasers playbook by slow-walking or ignoring intelligence-agency alarms about Russian interference in our elections past, present, and future. His congressional antecedents did the same when Germany tried to sabotage the election of 1940. As the story is told by Susan Dunn, a historian at Williams College, in her 2013 book1940,the charg daffaires at the German Embassy in Washington, Hans Thomsen, wielded money, a cohort of isolationist congressmen, senators, and authors, and a bag of dirty tricks, hoping to realize goals tantamount to Putins ambitions: to convince Americans that fascist aggression posed no danger to them, to discourage them from pouring billions of dollars into national defense and military aid for the Allies, and, finally, to engineer Roosevelts defeat in 1940.

Even without social media in his arsenal, Thomsens dirty tricks uncannily anticipated Russias 21st-century disinformation tactics. He funneled financial aid to an isolationist Make Europe Pay War Debts Committee to rile up Americans against European allies, lent aid to ostensibly grassroots organizations with names like Paul Reveres Sentinels rallying against American entry into war with Germany, and clandestinely underwrote newspaper ads lobbying for the same. With a secret subsidy, he paid an isolationist congressman, Hamilton Fish of New York, to corral anti-interventionist colleagues before a GOP convention platform committee to push a resolution unequivocally opposing any American involvement in the war in Europe. Thomsen even helped engineer a fake news stunt worthy of Russias propaganda schemes on Facebook by using the isolationist Montana representative Jacob Thorkelson to slip a counterfeit Hitler interview into theCongressional Record.It had Hitler telling a reporter that American fears of him were flattering but grotesque and calling the idea of a German invasion of the United States stupid and fantastic.

Any historical parallels, alas, end there. Germanys attempted election sabotage failed in 1940. The Republicans nominated Wendell Willkie, an interventionist, as their presidential candidate, rather than an isolationist favored by the Nazis, and the reelected FDR led America to war. By contrast, Russia may have succeeded in moving the electoral needle in 2016, and may again in 2020, with the blessings of the Putin-admiring American president and his quisling of a secretary of State Pompeo, not to mention the pliant Moscow Mitch, the double-dealing Barr, and the rest of their collaborators in the executive branch and Congress.

Those who continue with Trump on this path, if they have any shred of conscience or patriotism left, would be advised to look at their historical predecessors of the appeasement era, not the more forgiving template of Watergate, if they wish to game out their future and that of family members who bear their names. They might recall that Lindbergh was among the most popular figures, if not the most popular, in the nation before lending his voice to America First. He had won the cheers of the world after piloting the first nonstop solo flight over the Atlantic and then its sympathy after his 20-month-old son was murdered in a sensational kidnapping case. More than a decade after V-E Day, when Hollywood decided it was at last safe to profitably resurrect that heroic young Lindbergh in an adulatory 1957 biopic,The Spirit of St. Louis,some theaters refused to book it despite the added halo of the most unimpeachable all-American star, Jimmy Stewart ofMr. Smith Goes to Washington.Jack Warner reputedly called it the most disastrous failure in the history of Warner Bros. In the following decade, Lindbergh inched back into the spotlight as a philanthropist campaigning for the World Wildlife Fund. I dont want history to record my generation as being responsible for the extermination of any form of life, he declared, prompting the popular syndicated columnist Max Lerner to respond, Where the hell was he when Hitler was trying to exterminate an entire race of human beings?

Some of Lindberghs fellow isolationists sought to reclaim their reputations after the war, too, but as the historian Geoffrey Perret wrote, they would generally be regarded for years to come as stupid, vicious, pro-Nazi reactionaries, or at least as people blind to the realities of a new day and a menace to their countrys safety. Taft, the rigidly isolationist senator who bore a White House lineage (William Howard Taft was his father), failed in two subsequent presidential runs after his first attempt imploded as France fell to the Germans in 1940. Once known as the towering Mr. Republican, he now is barely remembered even by Republicans.

A comparable figure in England was Lord Londonderry, n Charles Vane-Tempest-Stewart, a former Tory British air minister whose entanglement with Nazi leaders and push for Anglo-German friendship in the 1930s mirrors Trump, Michael Flynn, Paul Manafort, and their posses infatuated courtship of Putins Russia. As the English Hitler biographer Ian Kershaw writes inMaking Friends With Hitler,Londonderry spent his later years in a relentless, but fruitless, campaign for vindication. Was he, as his detractors claimed, a genuine Nazi sympathizer a Nazi Englishman as he was dubbed? Or was he merely a gullible, nave and misguided fellow-traveler of the Right? Though Londonderry had no truck with the fanatical fascists, or the wide-eyed cranks and mystics who fell for Hitler lock, stock and barrel, Kershaw concludes, in the end it didnt matter.His actions worked to Hitlers advantage, and his reputation was ruined. His fitting permanent memorial is Lord Darlington, the fictional English aristocrat whose outreach to the Nazis and ensuing downfall are observed with a certain sorrow and pity by his butler, Stevens, in Kazuo Ishiguros classic novelThe Remains of the Day.

No less a sage than Ted Cruz told friends while preparing his 2016 convention speech that history isnt kind to the man who holds Mussolinis jacket, according to the Politico journalist Tim Albertas account inAmerican Carnage.But so harsh was the bases blowback after he refused to endorse Trump in that address that he has been holding Mussolinis jacket ever since.

What are Cruz and all his peers afraid of? Every member of the French Resistance faced the strong possibility of torture, deportation, and death, wrote Charles Kaiser, whose bookThe Cost of Couragetells of one Resistance family during Vichy. The most a Republican senator risks from opposing a corrupt and racist president is a loss at the polls. And even at that, there can be rewards down the road. Larry Hogan, the current Republican governor of Maryland,recently reminisced to the New YorkTimesabout his father, Lawrence Hogan, who was the first Republican on the House Judiciary Committee to come out in favor of impeaching Nixon in 1974. He lost friends in Congress, the younger Hogan recalled. He lost the support of his constituents and he angered the White House. But history was kind to him. He was known as a courageous guy. I think its the thing he is most remembered for and the thing Im most proud of him for.

Trumps enablers and collaborators are more Londonderry than Hogan. It is too late for them to save their reputations. We must hope that it is not too late to save the country they have betrayed.

Annotation

Some of Trumps most loyal supporters in Congress despise him in private. Veteran GOP strategist and early Never Trumper Rick Wilson has become a keeper of their secrets.

Illustration: Zohar Lazar

Trumps supporters in Congress call you to vent about how much they hate him. What are they hiding? Right after Trump was elected, there were a lot of guys who had this shocking moment. A friend of mine, a member of Congress, went home to a town-hall meeting, and a guy asks him, Are you going to be with Mr. Trump 100 percent of the time? And he goes, Well, look, I support Donald Trump and I want to help him, and we agree on many things. But I represent this district. If theres something the president wants to do and its good for us, were absolutely going to do it. If its something thats bad for our district, Im going to oppose it.

That, by the way, is the big tell. The people who call him Mr. Trump, you know theyre going to be a problem.

By the time he left the stage, his wife had death threats. His kids had death threats. Because he wouldnt say, Ill be with Trump no matter what. He called me two days later, and he said, I dont know what to do. Eventually he goes, Im going to keep my seat. He still privately bitches and moans, but hes still in Congress.

How do they express their fear to you? A few months ago, there was a Republican elected official at a party at my home. He gets there, and theres a conservative-leaning reporter. And the official absolutely loses his shit with me. Hes like, Oh my God, Im so fucked! Hes going to write about it.

I told him, No, these parties are always off the record. You know that. He goes, But theyre going to know they find out. If Im seen with you, the National Republican Congressional Committee will kill me.

And it just struck me, This is how they live every day? This fear that theyre going to get caught not even saying anything bad about the president but with somebody, or at a party at somebodys house, who is critical of the president.

What is it about Trump specifically that theyre upset by? Theres a good degree of it that is just the vulgar nature of Trump that hes not of a conservative mien or affect. The belittling of people, the way he goes after people that he perceives are inferior or vulnerable. The comments about John McCain actually affected a lot more Republicans than they let on. But theres also contempt that Trump doesnt understand any of this. He doesnt have any understanding of conservative economics or philosophy, but he is really great at playing the cop.

There were a lot of people around the time of the Charlottesville shooting who were generally appalled. When Trump doubled down and just kept digging, there was a moment where a lot of folks were like, Oh, now what do we do? We thought hed learn a lesson, or that he would take something from that disaster. But it didnt change anything. That was one of the peak moments of What the fuck do we do? among the party guys.

Theres also a general frustration about a lot of the things that conservatives would like to do on the policy side, in terms of entitlement reform and deregulation. The nut Ive tried hardest to crack is getting even the retired guys to go on the record.

How often are you having these conversations? Its dropped off since the midterms, but I still talk to somebody at least once a week. I spoke with someone who was at a White House event this spring, and this person stood there, did the whole stand behind the president, clap about his great accomplishments and was literally on the phone with me in the car on the way out.

Do you ever suggest that their silence is enabling Trump? Of course. And you know what they say? Youre absolutely right.

Photo credit (top): Mark Wilson/Getty (Mick Mulvaney); The Washington Post /Getty (Lindsay Graham); OLIVIER DOULIERY/Getty (William Barr); Win McNamee/Getty (David Nunes);Ethan Miller/Getty (Jerry Falwell Jr.); SOPA Images/Getty (Tom Cotton); JIM WATSON/Getty (Stephen Schwartzman); The Washington Post/Getty (Mark Meadows); Samuel Corum/Getty (Matt Gaetz); Bloomberg/Getty (Sarah Huckabee Sanders); Peter Summers/Getty (Mike Pence); Scott Olson/Getty (Rand Paul); Pacific Press/Getty (Nikki Haley); Anadolu Agency/Getty (Rick Perry); Noam Galai/Getty (Rudy Giuliani); Roy Rochlin/Getty (Tucker Carlson); Taylor Hill/Getty (Sean Hannity)Mark Wilson/Getty (Mick Mulvaney); The Washington Post /Getty (Lindsay Graham); OLIVIER DOULIERY/Getty (William Barr); Win McNamee/Getty (David Nunes);Ethan Miller/Getty (Jerry Falwell Jr.); SOPA Images/Getty (Tom Cotton); JIM WATSON/Getty (Stephen Schwartzman); The Washington Post/Getty (Mark Meadows); Samuel Corum/Getty (Matt Gaetz); Bloomberg/Getty (Sarah Huckabee Sanders); Peter Summers/Getty (Mike Pence); Scott Olson/Getty (Rand Paul); Pacific Press/Getty (Nikki Haley); Anadolu Agency/Getty (Rick Perry); Noam Galai/Getty (Rudy Giuliani); Roy Rochlin/Getty (Tucker Carlson); Taylor Hill/Getty (Sean Hannity)

*This article appears in the January 6, 2020, issue ofNew York Magazine. Subscribe Now!

The one story you shouldn't miss today, selected byNew York's editors.

Here is the original post:

What Will Happen to The Trump Toadies? - New York Magazine

Category: Holocaust Denial
Tags: