Posted By  admin on July 17, 2017    
				
				    LONDON  Those close to the Rabbi Joseph Dweck affair have    described is as a behemoth of an issue. Its a suitably    biblical term for what might seem, on the face of it, an arcane    spat between British religious scholars over the permissibility     or not  of homosexuality.  
    But, in fact, the repercussions of a lecture which seemingly    condoned homosexual relationships that Dweck delivered in    London this past May go far beyond that. At stake could be the    Jewish religious status of anyone who has availed themselves of    the rabbis services, whether for circumcision, conversion or    marriage.   
    The uproar follows a 97-minute talk the rabbi gave to members    of the Ner Yisrael Community in Hendon, northwest London, on    homosexuality in Jewish law.  
    [W]e have to see ultimately how it is we deal with it in terms    of Torah and society, Dweck said at the lecture. If we do not    hang our prejudices at the door when we deal with it, and dont    look at Torah as it is and what it is saying to us, and stop    with the insane bigotry and prejudice weve got, we will be on    the out and society will move forward because [God] doesnt    wait for anybody. He is taking His world into love.  
    As the senior rabbi of the Spanish and Portuguese congregation     and thus, effectively, the titular head of Britains small    but vibrant Sephardi Jewish community  the Los Angeles-born    rabbi has attracted a devoted following since taking up his    post three years ago.  
      Now deceased Shas spiritual leader Rabbi Ovadia Yosef seen      with his son Chief Rabbi Yitzhak Yosef during a ceremony      inaugurating the latter as the Sephardic chief rabbi of      Israel at the at the Rabban Yohanan Ben Zakai Synagogue in      Jerusalem old city on September 16, 2013. (Yonatan      Sindel/Flash90)    
    Dweck studied in Jerusalem under the tutelage of the late    Sephardi chief rabbi of Israel, Rabbi Ovadia Yosef, whose    granddaughter, Margalit, he married.  
    Before coming to London, Dweck served as rabbi of Congregation    Shaare Shalom, a Syrian Sephardi synagogue of over 700 members,    in Brooklyn, New York, from 1999 to 2014. For the last five    years of his time in the US, he was also headmaster of Barkai    Yeshivah, a large Jewish day school in Brooklyn.  
    While in the running for the London job, Dweck contended    against and beat out Rabbi David Bassous, whose brother, Rabbi    Aharon Bassous, heads a small Sephardi community in London. The    latter Bassous has spearheaded the outcry against Dwecks    lecture.  
    This history may have colored Dwecks most recent tweets, one    of which quotes poet Robert Frosts axiom that The afternoon    knows what the morning never suspected.  
      Rabbi Joseph Dweck speaks at a Lights Out WWI Remembrance      Ceremony at the Bevis Marks Synagogue on August 4, 2014, in      London, United Kingdom. (Dan Dennison/Getty Images/via JTA)    
    Though Dweck began his lecture with disclaimers warning of the    trepidation hed felt while preparing it and of the controversy    he suspected it might cause, he did not anticipate the fallout    that would ensue on three continents.  
    During the course of the speech, he said that the Torah had    little to say about homosexuality and that, although sexual    intercourse between men was forbidden, men could love each    other in other ways.  
    He also said that he genuinely believe[s] the entire    revolution of feminism and even homosexuality in our society    is a fantastic development for humanity.  
    In response, during a two-hour lecture to his own Golders Green    Sephardi community Aharon Bassous described Dwecks talk as    false and misguided corrupt from beginning to end.  
    Throughout Jewish history, there have been those who deviate    from the Torah the reformers, Conservative, Liberal and their    ilk, Bassous said. But theyre not dangerous, because we know    where we stand, and we know where they stand.  
      From the outside, hes Orthodox, but his mouth spouts      Reform    
    When is it dangerous? When you have someone who comes in front    of you with two hats, he continued. Hes got the hat of an    Orthodox and the hat of a Reform. From the outside, hes    Orthodox, but his mouth spouts Reform.  
    Where have we had this before in Anglo Jewry? Louis Jacobs.    Rabbi Dweck is another Louis Jacobs. Its not only this talk.    Ive heard subsequent talks, and hes even more poisonous than    Louis Jacobs.  
    The late Rabbi Louis Jacobs founded the Masorti movement in    Britain, causing a schism with mainstream Orthodox Jewry in the    early 1960s. After a public conflict with the then-chief rabbi    Israel Brodie, Jacobs  accompanied by many of his congregation     set up the New London Synagogue.  
    For many, the Jacobs affair, which became a cause celebre in    the general British media, was a watershed for Anglo Jewry. But    its ramifications still echo in the country today as unions    blessed by the Masorti rabbinate are not recognized by clergy    under the aegis of the Chief Rabbi. There are many recorded    instances of people marrying in both a Masorti and an Orthodox    synagogue in order to get a valid ketubah, or marriage    certificate.  
    In addition to objecting to the contents of Dwecks    homosexuality lecture, Bassous claimed that the rabbi made    dubious rulings during other classes, such as granting    permission to watch TV or ride a bicycle on Shabbat. Soon,    within Orthodox circles, controversial quotes from Dweck    lectures began circulating.  
    Two weeks after the original lecture, both Chief Rabbi Ephraim    Mirvis and the London Beth Din were distancing themselves from    the situation, saying that as Dweck was a senior Sephardi    rabbi, he did not fall under Mirviss control.  
    Nevertheless, there were private meetings between Dweck and    Mirvis, who also spoke to the Spanish and Portuguese community.  
    Adding fuel to the fire, Rabbi Yitzhak Yosef, the present    Rishon lZion, or Sephardi chief rabbi of Israel,    addressed a letter to rabbis of the Syrian community in New    York which argued that Dweck was not qualified to be a rabbi    and urged his former colleagues to dissociate themselves from    him.  
      The Archbishop of Cantebury Justin Welby (l) and the British      Chief Rabbi Ephraim Mirvis, visit the Western Wall, Judaisms      holiest site, in Jerusalems Old City, on May 3, 2017.      (Yonatan Sindel/Flash90)    
    Yosef is the son of the former chief rabbi Ovadiah Yosef and is    the uncle of Dwecks wife.  
    This has severe reverberations in the Sephardi world, a    source told The Times of Israel. The Spanish and Portuguese    community in London cannot continue with a rabbi who does not    have the blessing of the Rishon lZion.  
      The Spanish and Portuguese community in London cannot      continue with a rabbi who does not have the blessing of the      Rishon lZion    
    Other commentators have said it is no coincidence that Dweck    regularly returns to the US to give lectures in the summer.  
    However, last month, Dweck canceled his annual summer job as    scholar in residence at a major Sephardi summer institute in    New Jersey to deal with the fallout from his comments. He has    allegedly made himself unpopular with some members of the    Syrian community  including those who are said to be serious    funders of Yosefs office.  
    Following the first letter, Yosef wrote another to dayan    (rabbinical judge), Rabbi Yaakov Yisroel Lichtenstein, who is    the head of Londons Federation of Synagogues, an Orthodox    Ashkenazi denomination which technically does not recognize the    authority of Mirvis.  
    In this letter, Yosef asked Lichtenstein to convene a beit    din (rabbinical court) and effectively hold a trial of    Dweck.  
    Lichtenstein reported this to the Federation of Synagogues lay    leadership  which, uncomfortable with the request, insisted on    non-Federation rabbis joining the proposed beit din.  
    They first looked to Mirvis, but he turned Lichtenstein down    flat, saying privately that he did not wish to be involved in    what he deemed a kangaroo court a medieval show trial.  
    Ultimately, Lichtenstein told Yosef that he could not convene a    Beth Din as had been requested.  
      Sephardi Chief Rabbi Yitzhak Yosef meets with newly appointed      Supreme Rabbinical Court judges in Jerusalem, July 13, 2016.      (Photo by Yaacov Cohen/Flash90)    
    As the weeks rolled on the controversy escalated, with    influential rabbis, both pro- and anti-Dweck, taking    increasingly public sides. Externally, things proceeded as    usual in the Spanish and Portuguese community.  
    In mid-June, community president Sabah Zubaida issued a letter    to his congregation which said, A great deal of the criticism    has been based on misunderstandings, some deliberate and some    not. However, Rabbi Dweck accepts that some of the criticism is    justified and needs to be addressed within the wider rabbinical    world.  
    At that point it became clear that what had began as a witch    hunt, as Dwecks supporters called it, had developed into a    legitimate controversy over some of his halachic rulings and    aspersions he had cast on rabbinical colleagues.  
      People hadnt really paid attention to what he had been      saying until Rabbi Bassous went after him    
    The homosexual lecture was the trigger for all this, one    insider said. People hadnt really paid attention to what he    had been saying until Rabbi Bassous went after him  and then    there was a new focus on his halachic rulings and a realization    that some of them were really suspect.  
    Concerns were expressed over rulings he was said to have made,    including the switching on of fluorescent lights after sunset    on a Friday, as well as allowing payment with a credit card for    flu medication on Shabbat.  
    According to a group of rabbis critical of Dweck, he had said    that some of his colleagues could be dishonest in their    rulings, and that, No rabbi, however long his beard is,    however long he has learned, can say you cant ride a bike [on    Shabbat] Theyre not allowed to.  
    Seeking to temper some of the heat, Dweck made an apology to a    WhatsApp group of more than 100 rabbis over his repeated    criticisms of their rulings. Not everyone was charmed. One    rabbi said it was too little, too late, though others were    said to have been impressed that he had apologized at all.  
      A photo from circa the 1930s of the Gateshead yeshiva.      (CC-SA-Cecily Davis)    
    Into this uproar waded the head rabbi of the prestigious    northeast British yeshiva at Gateshead, Rav Shraga Feivel    Zimmerman. In public letters Zimmerman said that Dweck was not    fit to serve due to his limited knowledge, weak halachic    reasoning skills, and lack of training.  
    And in the wake of Zimmermans denunciation, a group of    anonymous rabbis warned Mirvis, that if Joseph Dweck is    maintained in office as a rabbi, whether it is fully or even    partially, in spite of all the letters received from highly    respected Orthodox rabbinical authorities in Gateshead and in    Israel and worldwide, Chief Rabbi Mirvis should realize that he    will be responsible for the splitting of Anglo-Orthodoxy and    lose his credibility as a Chief Rabbi to a large consensus of    Orthodox communities.  
      If Joseph Dweck is maintained in office Chief Rabbi Mirvis      will be responsible for the splitting of Anglo-Orthodoxy    
    In response, Jerusalems Rabbi Nathan Lopes Cardozo wrote an    open letter to the Gateshead leader, urging him to withdraw his    comments. Lopes Cardozo, who studied in Gateshead, said he felt    it was his moral and halachic duty to defend Dweck.  
    He said that the letter warning Mirvis that he would be    responsible for a split in the community was blackmail and    that some rabbis seem to have lost all sense of proportion.  
    Meanwhile, behind the scenes, a contrite Dweck was asking for    Mirviss help, Mirvis was aware that he could not become    involved in this complex war of words without the backing of    Yosef.  
    As battle intensified in public  this week it was announced    that Zimmerman would be making a rare public appearance at    Aharon Bassouss synagogue, presumably to ramp up the rhetoric     in private Mirvis was seeking a missing piece on the    chess-board: a blessing from the Sephardi chief rabbi.  
      Sephardic Chief Rabbi Yitzhak Yosef. (Yonatan Sindel/Flash90)    
    Finally, after days of delicate negotiations, Mirvis received    the letter for which he had been waiting. In it, Yosef says:    Seeing as I am not fully familiar with the context of Jewish    community life in England, I request from his Eminence, who    carries the glory of Torah on his shoulders, in his capacity as    Chief Rabbi of England, to take responsibility for dealing with    the matter and to reach a decision based on his understanding    of the situation. If he finds it necessary, he may appoint a    beit din, or any other suitable format, which will    enable him to bring the matter to a final resolution. Whatever    he decides will be acceptable to us in Israel.  
    The crucial words are any other suitable format, as well as    the last sentence acknowledging Mirviss authority. As chief    rabbi, Mirvis is one of the few people in the world who can    draw a line under the Dweck affair, but the letters continue to    pour into his office, almost exactly split down the middle    between supporting Dweck and demanding he lose his job.  
      It is an urgent communal priority    
    Now, Mirvis has the thankless task of putting in place a    credible process to deal with Dweck. He is all too aware that    whatever he does, some will not be satisfied. But, The Times of    Israel has been told, Mirvis considers this to be an urgent    communal priority.  
    With a row echoing in three countries, the last thing Mirvis    wants is a repeat of the Louis Jacobs Affair. The process is    being deliberately kept under wraps, with no time frame; no one    knows whether a beit din is being convened, or whether    Dweck will be questioned closely simply by Mirvis himself.  
    It will take as long as it takes, says a source close to the    Chief Rabbi. It is one of the burdens of office. But the    implications for conversions, marriages, children  the unity    of the Jewish world is literally at stake.  
    JTA contributed to this report.  
  From left to right: Rabbi Joseph Dweck (courtesy), British Chief  Rabbi Ephraim Mirvis (Foreign and Commonwealth Office), and Chief  Sephardi Rabbi od Israel Yitzhak Yosef (CC-SA-GFDL).
Continue reading here: 
Is UK's Sephardi rabbi fracas about more than condoning homosexuality? - The Times of Israel
				
Category: Sephardic |  
Comments Off on Is UK’s Sephardi rabbi fracas about more than condoning homosexuality? – The Times of Israel                     
Tags: